There’s nothing more quintessentially Cape Cod than indulging in ice cream after a day spent on the beach or following a leisurely seafood dinner. From waffle cones to soft serve, shakes to frappes, dipped cones to sprinkle-covered delights, nothing beats a mouth-watering cone on a hot summer night.
With hundreds of ice cream spots to choose from, making a decision can be daunting. That’s where we come in! We're here to guide sweet-toothed travelers to the best ice cream places on the Cape for this season. Based on exceptional service, diverse menus, and stellar reviews, we present our top picks!
Aunties’ Ice Cream Parlor (Dennisport)
Aunties’ Ice Cream Parlor is a year-round destination serving up some of the best homemade ice cream on the Cape. With old-fashioned frappes, malts, sundaes, smoothies, Lime Rickeys, and more, this place is a must-visit.
Cape Cod Creamery (Hyannis, South Yarmouth, & Dennis)
Known for its flavorful and creamy ice cream, Cape Cod Creamery offers a gourmet experience with a plethora of delightful flavors. Light, sweet, and utterly delicious, this spot is a treat for all ice cream lovers. You’ll especially love the take on Cape Cod’s favorite locales in the names of what is sure to become your favorite flavors of ice cream! My very favorite is Allen Harbor Almond Joy! A truly delightful treat!
Emack & Bolio’s Ice Cream (Chatham, Orleans, & Wellfleet)
Emack & Bolio’s stands out for its unique flavors and fantastic sweet treats. Their gourmet ice cream is a summer highlight at any of their locations. I recall going when we first moved to the Cape and have the fondest memories of discovering all their yummiest flavors! What’s yours?
Four Seas Ice Cream (Centerville)
Serving the finest homemade ice cream since 1934, Four Seas offers old-fashioned ice cream sundaes, sodas, frappes, and more. Step back in time and savor a sweet treat at this beloved spot.
Ice Cream Cafe (Orleans)
This cafe offers homemade scooped ice cream, premium soft serve, baked goods, fresh fruit drinks, and non-dairy options. There’s something for everyone with a sweet craving here.
Katie’s Homemade Ice Cream (Hyannis)
Katie’s serves up incredible homemade ice cream with innovative twists alongside classic flavors. They also offer fresh baked cookies, coffee, and much more! It’s a Must Stop if you want to be sure you don’t want to miss out on a great culinary experience!
Lewis Brothers Ice Cream (Provincetown)
A family-owned business since 1997, Lewis Brothers Ice Cream offers homemade classics including banana splits, frappes, and more, making it a perfect stop for traditional ice cream lovers.
Nauset Ice Cream (Eastham)
Locally owned and operated since 1998, Nauset Ice Cream makes fresh ice cream daily. Don’t miss out on this sweet spot on your next Cape trip!
Smitty’s Homemade Ice Cream (Falmouth)
Smitty’s has been serving premium homemade ice cream in Falmouth since 2002, crafting each small batch with care.
Sundae School (Dennis & Harwichport)
Open since 1976, Sundae School offers a delicious educational experience with a marble soda fountain over 100 years old. There’s plenty to taste and see at this historic spot.
Twin Acres Ice Cream Shoppe (Sandwich)
For those seeking variety, Twin Acres offers 70 flavors including premium hard, soft serve, sorbet, sherbet, vegan, and no sugar added options.
Sweet Izzy is the first and only completely plant-based ice cream shop on Cape Cod. Everything we make is plant-based, dairy-free, soy-free, gluten-free and vegan.
Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe (Dennisport)
What began as a real estate purchase of a condemned property in Gloucester, MA, unexpectedly evolved into a passion for creating remarkable ice cream that wows with every flavor. From unique combos like Salted Butter Cracker Ice Cream with Ritz Cracker Toffee Bark to house-made mix-ins, we don’t cut corners and enjoy surprising our customers. Our menu balances diverse classics with nostalgic treats, offering everything from Fruity Pebbles cereal milk to Zebra Cake ice cream. The experience at Holy Cow is marked by eye-catching aesthetics and the enticing smell of made-to-order waffle cones, making each visit memorable. We also prioritize giving back to our community, aiming to create a relationship with our customers that goes beyond transactions through engaging charitable initiatives.
Ice Cream Smuggler (Dennis)
Paul and Carter Catalano invite you to savor The Ice Cream Smuggler’s 27 homemade ice cream flavors and 4 frozen yogurt varieties, alongside sherbets, sorbets, and sugar-free options. Enjoy your treat in a sugar, cake, waffle, chocolate-dipped sugar or waffle cone, or a chocolate-dipped waffle bowl. The Smuggler also offers sundaes, brownie sundaes, banana splits, frappes, malts, ice cream sodas, and sherbet or sorbet freezes. Hand-packed pints and quarts are available for purchase. Since acquiring the Smuggler in 2005, the Catalanos have upheld the original recipes and traditions passed down by previous owners Alan and Maggi Tyson, continuing to make small batches of ice cream daily using the finest ingredients, just as they did in 1979.
Indulge in the best Cape Cod has to offer with these top ice cream spots. Each one promises a memorable and delightful experience for every ice cream enthusiast!
Are you dreaming of a getaway to Cape Cod, the picturesque gem of Massachusetts? Planning the perfect accommodation is a crucial part of turning your vacation into a memorable experience. Look no further – navigating through our collection of properties is a breeze.
Our user-friendly website, www.seashorerentalscapecod.com, allows you to effortlessly explore various options, each accompanied by detailed descriptions and high-quality images. Find the property that speaks to you and fits your vacation vision seamlessly, and book instantly right online.
